Narrative-Aware Moderation Dials for Recovery and Harm-Reduction Communities

Create dynamic “moderation dials” that adjust enforcement strategies across a spectrum—from strict takedowns to interactive/motivational interventions—based on real-time community resilience and crisis risk signals. Policies encode when to encourage narrative experimentation versus when to intervene, with human-in-the-loop escalation. This formal policy design unifies insights that moderate regulation enables narrative experimentation in sensitive communities, automated systems are often too risk-averse, and harm-reduction moderators need expert risk assessment and example-based tools. It moves beyond binary remove/allow decisions by specifying a state-aware policy preferring supportive interventions in gray areas, using semi-automated prompts and example-based moderator tooling rather than brittle rules. This approach prevents over-suppression of beneficial narratives while retaining safeguards for crisis scenarios. Impact includes improved health outcomes and trust in sensitive communities while reducing unintended chilling effects of automated moderation.

References:

1. Men in online eating disorder recovery spaces: Gendered barriers, content moderation, and narrative experimentation. Connor B. S. Strobel, Jayna Lennon (2023). Sociology Compass.
2. A Human-is-the-Loop Approach for Semi-Automated Content Moderation. D. Link, B. Hellingrath, Jie Ling (2016). International Conference on Information Systems for Crisis Response and Management.
3. MODERATING MENTAL HEALTH: ARE AUTOMATED SYSTEMS TOO RISK AVERSE?. Anthony McCosker (2023). AoIR Selected Papers of Internet Research.
4. Critical Challenges in Content Moderation for People Who Use Drugs (PWUD): Insights into Online Harm Reduction Practices from Moderators. Kaixuan Wang, Loraine Clarke, Carl-Cyril J Dreue, Guancheng Zhou, Jason T. Jacques (2025). arXiv.org.
5. Navigating the gray areas of content moderation: Professional moderators’ perspectives on uncivil user comments and the role of (AI-based) technological tools. Andrea Stockinger, Svenja Schäfer, S. Lecheler (2023). New Media & Society.